Waiting in the Hallway – The Murder of Kanika Powell

Kanika Powell did everything right.

That’s the detail that makes this case so difficult to sit with. So often, when we cover a story on this show, there’s a moment where you can point to something — a warning sign ignored, a risk taken, a door left unlocked. With Kanika, there isn’t one. She checked every story. She called every number. She warned every person in her life. And it still wasn’t enough.

A Week of Warnings

In the last week of August 2008, Kanika Powell — a 28-year-old Army veteran living alone in Laurel, Maryland — experienced three separate visits from strangers at her apartment door.

The first came on a Saturday evening: a man claiming to be an FBI agent, holding what looked like a badge up to her peephole, addressing her by name. Kanika refused to open the door without proper identification. When he left, she didn’t just let it go — she called the local FBI field office directly to ask whether an agent had actually been sent to see her. They told her no, and that if they ever did need to speak with her, it would never be a single agent, alone, at her apartment.

She called the police. She called her rental office. She emailed her friends and family with a full account of what had happened, ending her message with a warning to the women in her life to be careful about who they let through their doors.

Four days later, a second stranger showed up, this time posing as a delivery driver with a package requiring a signature. Kanika hadn’t ordered anything. She refused to open the door and called the shipping carrier, who had no record of any delivery scheduled for her address. A cousin who lived across the street caught a glimpse of the man as he walked away — no truck, no vehicle, nothing to explain how he’d arrived or where he went.

Twelve hours after that, before eight in the morning, a third knock. Another claim of a package. Kanika had had enough of walking into the dark to run errands after work, so she made a decision: she’d take the morning off, get her car serviced in daylight, and be home safe well before evening.

She never got the chance to be anywhere else.

What Happened That Morning

Around 11:50 AM on August 28th, 2008, Kanika returned to her apartment complex after running her errands. Someone was waiting for her in the hallway.

Neighbors reported hearing her voice — clear and frightened — before a series of gunshots rang out. One neighbor, smelling gunpowder in the air, looked over his balcony and found her on the floor below. He called for help immediately.

Kanika was rushed to the hospital, but her injuries were too severe. She died the following day, on August 29th. She was 28 years old.

Her purse. Her car keys. Every item of value she’d been carrying was found untouched beside her. Whoever did this hadn’t come to rob her. They had come for her, specifically — and they knew exactly who they were looking for.

Who Was Kanika

It would be easy, in a case like this, to let Kanika become a set of case details — a timeline, a list of suspects, a mystery to be solved. She was so much more than that.

She was the daughter Judy Powell Forrest named after “black cloth” — a term that, once Judy dug deeper into it, turned out to represent something sacred. She was the girl who moved in across the street from a family that would come to think of her as a second daughter, and the friend who stayed close to that family for the next fifteen years. She served in the Army, spent her final year overseas in Korea, and came home to a first office job she was proud of — a security specialist role with a top-secret clearance at a lab tied to national defense work.

She was private about her career, the way people are when their work simply isn’t something they’re allowed to discuss. She was, by every account, a homebody — someone who worked, came home, and kept a small, steady circle of people close to her.

And in the summer of 2008, she was falling for someone. Kanika was bisexual, and had recently begun seeing a woman. The two of them were planning a trip to Atlanta together for that August’s Pride festival — a trip Kanika never got to take.

An Investigation Without Answers

The detective who caught Kanika’s case in 2008, Sergeant Gregory McDonald, still carries her file today as head of the Prince George’s County Cold Case Squad. Ballistic evidence recovered from the scene has been checked against every handgun recovered in the county — and nationally — in the years since. There has never been a match. The weapon has never been found.

Investigators looked hard at the most obvious theory first: that Kanika’s top-secret clearance and government-adjacent job had something to do with her death. They found nothing connecting the two. They turned to her personal life next, and found a woman with no known enemies, no conflicts, nothing that would explain why anyone would want her dead.

What they were left with is what remains true today: no weapon, no eyewitness, and — as of the most recent statement on record — no person of interest in the murder of Kanika Powell.

The Theories

Over nearly two decades, a handful of theories have followed this case, though not all of them hold up equally well.

The theory Kanika’s own mother and closest friend return to most often involves a new friend group Kanika had recently begun spending time with — specifically, the ex-boyfriend of the woman she’d started dating. It’s a theory built on impressions rather than hard evidence, but it’s notable that none of Kanika’s new friends, including the woman she was seeing, ever appeared at the hospital or the funeral after her death.

The theory that’s followed this case the longest — that her murder was somehow tied to her security clearance and classified work — remains the one with the least evidentiary support, despite being the most frequently repeated online.

Some coverage of this case has pointed to Jason Thomas Scott, a serial killer convicted in two other Prince George’s County double-homicides who used his job at UPS to identify and stalk victims. Scott and Kanika even attended the same high school. But investigators looked directly at Scott in connection with Kanika’s case and ruled him out — his method didn’t match, and he never operated in the part of the county where Kanika lived.

And a few months after Kanika’s death, another government employee with a top-secret clearance, Sean Green, was shot and killed nearby under equally mysterious circumstances. Investigators found no connection between the two cases, despite the eerie parallel.

What Kanika Left Behind

Years after her death, Kanika’s mother, Judy, shared her own story with Everytown for Gun Safety’s “Moments That Survive” project — a space where families affected by gun violence tell their stories in their own words. It’s a reminder that this case isn’t only a mystery. It’s also, quietly, a story about what gun violence leaves behind long after the headlines fade: a mother without an answer, a family with an empty seat, and a daughter whose name deserves to keep being said.

If You Know Something

Somebody knows who knocked on Kanika Powell’s door three times in the last week of her life. Somebody knows who was waiting for her in that hallway.

If you have any information about the murder of Kanika Powell, please contact the Prince George’s County Police Department at 301-352-1200, or PG County Crime Solvers anonymously at 1-866-411-TIPS or online at pgcrimesolvers.com. A reward of up to $25,000 is being offered for information leading to an arrest.

Listen to the full story on this week’s episode of Vanished Voices: Waiting in the Hallway – The Murder of Kanika Powell on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, YouTube or anywhere you listen to podcasts!

Vanished Voices is a true crime podcast dedicated to the cases that don’t get the attention they deserve — unsolved cases of people of color, LGBTQ+ victims, MMIW cases, and stories that still need tips to be solved. New episodes drop every Thursday. Subscribe and follow us anywhere you listen to podcasts.

Have thoughts on this story or other cases you’d like to see highlighted? Share them with us in the comments or connect with us on social media. Together, we can ensure that stories like this one are never forgotten.

Don’t forget to follow us on social media, @VanishedVoicesPod, share your thoughts, and let us know what you’d like to hear about in future episodes. If you have any true crime stories of your own, send them our way Vanishedvoicespodcast@gmail.com to be featured on a future episode! And as always, Refuse to let these voices vanish. See you in the next episode of Vanished Voices!

Resources:

Bensen, J. (2013, September 25). Man gets life in prison in death of a mother and her daughter. NBC4 Washington. Man Gets Life in Prison in Death of a Mother and Her Daughter – NBC4 Washington

Black Girl Gone: A True Crime Podcast. (n.d.). Killer in the shadows: The murder of Kanika Powell [Audio podcast episode].

CityTowner. (2024, December 17). Kanika Powell murder in Prince George’s County Maryland. https://citytowner.com/kanika-powell-pgc-md/

Davis, A. C. (2008, September 4). Prince George’s killing, apparently planned, opens host of mysteries. The Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/09/03/AR2008090304010.html

Detective Perspective. (2025, February 11). 76: Murder: Kanika Powell detective perspective [Audio podcast episode]. iHeartRadio. https://www.iheart.com/podcast/270-detective-perspective-119285635/episode/76-murder-kanika-powell-266494379/

Forrest, J. P. (n.d.). Kanika [Tribute]. Moments That Survive, Everytown for Gun Safety. Kanika

French, S. (Host). (2023, March 1). A killer comes knocking (No. 74). In Unsolved Mysteries. Cosgrove Meurer Productions & Cadence13, an Audacy company. https://cdn.unsolved.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/74-A-Killer-Comes-Knocking.pdf

GMA/ABC News. (2010, July 28). Maryland serial-killer suspect Jason Thomas Scott ‘evil,’ victim’s mom says. ABC News. Maryland Serial-Killer Suspect Jason Thomas Scott ‘Evil,’ Victim’s Mom Says – ABC News

HubPages. (2024, September 14). The unsolved murder of Kanika Powell. The Unsolved Murder of Kanika Powell – HubPages

Last Seen Alive. (2020, June 19). Unsolved homicide: Kanika Powell [Audio podcast episode & show notes]. UNSOLVED HOMICIDE: KANIKA POWELL – LAST SEEN ALIVE

Legacy.com. (2008, September 4). Kanika Powell obituary. Originally published in The Washington Post. Kanika Powell Obituary (2008) – Washington, DC – The Washington Post

Murderpedia. (n.d.). Jason Thomas Scott. Jason Thomas Scott | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers

Oxygen.com. (2023, December 30). Jason Thomas Scott convicted as Maryland ‘mother-daughter killer.’ How A Leaf And A ‘Spooky House’ Led To Conviction of Maryland ‘Mother-Daughter Killer’ | Oxygen

Sigona, M. (2015, October 9). Unsolved: National security worker gunned down amid mysterious circumstances. True Crime News. Unsolved: National security worker gunned down amid mysterious circumstances

True Case Files. (2019, August 17). The murder of Kanika Powell. True Case Files: The Murder of Kanika Powell

Washington Post. (2008, August 31). Regional briefing. The Washington Post. REGIONAL BRIEFING – The Washington Post